Group Blog
สิงหาคม 2550
18 สิงหาคม 2550
All Blogs
A Proportional Election System for Thailand?

Michael H. Nelson

The debate on how to improve the draft constitution prepared by the Constitution Drafting Committee included the surprising suggestion that Thailand should adopt the “German model” of personalized proportional representation or, as it is called in the international literature, mixed-member proportional system (MMP). This expres-sion indicates that there are two kinds of members of parliament (MP)—MPs directly elected in constituencies and party-list MPs—with proportionality being the main principle determining the allocation of seats to parties in an election. A number of Thai-language articles tried to explain and promote this system. Unfortunately, they contained a number of misleading and confusing mistakes that prevented readers from gaining an adequate understanding of this electoral system. Therefore, this brief arti-cle tries to provide some additional information in order to clarify the electoral issues involved.
Until the 1997 Constitution came into effect, the election system used in Thai-land was mostly a plurality system with multiple or block vote. In the last election based on this system, in 1996, there were 156 constituencies divided into seven sin-gle-member constituencies, 61 two-member and 88 three-member constituencies. Thus, there was no equality of the votes. The constitution of 1997 fundamentally changed this system. In the elections of 2001, 2005, and 2006 a plurality system with 400 single-member constituencies (SMC) was combined with proportional representa-tion. One hundred of the House of Representatives’ 500 seats were filled from closed and blocked party lists. In order to receive party-list MPs, a political party had to re-ceive at least five percent of the total number of votes, minus invalid ballots and ab-stentions. Voters thus equally had two votes, one for the constituency candidate and one for the party list. However, unlike in the German model, the constituency and party-list votes were applied separately in a segmented or parallel system, meaning that “Two electoral systems are used to elect members of a parliamentary chamber separately … These two parts of the segmented system are not connected in any way and their respective electoral formulae are also applied separately.” Systems similar to the one used in Thailand are found in Japan, South Korea and Taiwan. This system is also called mixed-member majoritarian (MMM), indicating that, like in MMP, there are two kinds of MPs, while the main principle for the allocation of seats is majori-tarian.

Download Full Text

Create Date : 18 สิงหาคม 2550
Last Update : 18 สิงหาคม 2550 12:55:58 น. 0 comments
Counter : 860 Pageviews.

ชื่อ :
Comment :
  *ใช้ code html ตกแต่งข้อความได้เฉพาะสมาชิก

Location :
สมุทรสงคราม Thailand

[ดู Profile ทั้งหมด]

ให้ทิปเจ้าของ Blog [?]
Rss Feed

ผู้ติดตามบล็อก : 7 คน [?]

Click for use Graphics comment

Darksingha ที่แสดงถึงอำนาจและความมืดมัว ผมให้แทนคำว่า Age of Doubt หรือยุคแห่งความสงสัยก็แล้วกัน ดังนั้นBlogนี้จึงเป็นแดนสนธยาที่เต็มไปด้วยหมอกควันแห่งคำถาม และการละเล่น เพื่อแสวงหา ?

TV3 Live CH5 Live CH7 Live Modernine TV Live NBT LIVE - CH11 TPBS - Public Channel ASTV1 New11 - Online News 24 hours Nation Channel DMC.TV - Buddhistic Television ASTV5 - Suvarnbhumi ASTV7 - Buddhistic Television  True New 24 Channel  skynew  cnnibn Channel  cnn Channel  bbcnews_island Channel  cctv  Channel  bfmtv  Channel  ntv  Channel  fox8 Channel  foxnews5 Channel  cspan  Channel  france24 Channel  world_explorer Channel  discovery_channel Channel  nasa  Channel kimeng-channel dmc-channel ebr-channel research-channel utv-channel michigan-channel at-florida-channel islam-channel peace-usa-channel bbc-panorama-channel CH7 Live CH7 Live CH7 Live CH7 Live CH7 Live CH7 Live CH7 Live CH7 Live

music is life


Friends' blogs
[Add Darksingha's blog to your web]
Links | | | © 2004 allrights reserved.