The massage that In the Valley of Elah trying to say is very simple yet intriguing. And its subtle enough to let we think for ourselves. This is a second directorial outing for Paul Haggis (of Oscar-winning Crash). Whereas Crash was shamelessly melodramatic and went waaay over the top, In the Valley of Elah felt more personal and closer to our heart.
Based on true event, Hank Deerfield (Tommy Lee Jones) is a retired Vietnam War veteran. His son, Mike, is also a soldier who has gone missing after got back from an Iraq War. Hank decided to go to Fort Rudd, New Mexico, where Mikes military base is. He began to do his own investigation with the help of local police, detective Emily (Charlize Theron). With more truth they have found out along the way, the more they faced with an ugliness of it.
You have to see it for yourself, so you can know how it perfectly used its title with a metaphor. In the Valley of Elah is the place where David confronts with Goliath. At the end, David who is weaker than his enemy in every possible way killed Goliath with a single blow (a rock with slingshot, that is). In one scene, Hank told this story to Emilys son and how it related to him and his sons situation. He said that David didnt only fight with Goliath but also fight with his own fear. David decided to stand still and wait for deliver one single shot that killed both of his enemy. Well, I think I will let you draw the line by yourself how two stories can be related, after you watch it, of course.
Although the story is very interesting, the execution was not as good as it supposed to be. There were plenty of investigation scene but most of them could not qualified for memorable one (even the chase scene). Sometimes, when the investigation is going on, I cant help but thinking of another tv-episode of CSI. Paul Haggis maybe capable as a writer, but as a director, he might need some more experiences.
I think the cast tried their best and by that, exceed the quality of direction itself. Tommy Lee Jones is so subtle and very well acted. For me, he is one of the underappreciated actors of our time (Only handful of people saw his masterpiece The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada). Charlize Theron is also underplayed her character well enough to create a room for Mr. Joness great performance. Anyway, this is the way her character supposed to be, and she did it so dutifully.
Many people complained about its ending. They said that its so over the top and way too obvious. They said this film shamelessly exploited their anti-Iraq Wars perspective. Well, I do agree one thing that, theyve emphasized the symbol a little bit too much. But I have to disagree with them that this is a bad ending. It is well intention kind of ending that sure to intact in people memory for a very long time. No matter how corny it is.
I totally agree that Tommy Lee Jones seems to be quite underrated these days ka. He needs more interesting roles instead of being typecasted as a sulking policeman/FBI all the time. Thanks for the insightful article na ka. I will definitely go out and buy a DVD of this movie ka.
apple_cinnamon Thanks for stopping by na krab. You're right that Mr. Jones needs some other role beside FBI/Policeman arr. Anyway I hope he will keep doing directing work arr.
You could have brain tumor by watching this contaminated turd. Nothing in Gentlemen Broncos pays off, it’s incoherent mess, and chock-full of incredibly annoying characters. You will not only loath this movie, but it also makes you want to punch someone who responsible for this abomination in the face.
BloodyMonday Rating:
Fantastic Mr. Fox (2009)
Imagine if Akira got Live-Action treatment by... say Alfonso Cuarón, you know how awesome it might be? That’s what happened to "Fantastic Mr. Fox". Wes Anderson's auteur perfectly captured the quirkiness and blissful tone of the material. Its stop-motion technique might be a little crude and... somewhat unsophisticated, but that's the charm of it. You’ll feel like pop-up book unveiled before your eyes. This is an exceptional animation of the year.
Up in the Air is a blockbuster movie for people who think blockbuster movies are dumb, as it chock full of brilliantly written dialogue, and acting showcase for three talented actors (especially star-making turn by Anna Kendrick). But in the end, there's little to love, not so much story to chew on (plus disappointing third act), and no real connection to the meaning of human interaction as it intended to be.
BloodyMonday Rating:
I Love You, Beth Cooper (2009)
Cliché-ridden plot about a bunch of annoying characters get together in one idiotic circumstance, "I Love You, Beth Cooper" is shameless exploitation & biggest insult to 80s teen flicks. It's like memorizing magic trick from internet, hoping to perform like David Copperfield. Neither sense of wonder nor magic flare happens here. Only good thing is, it makes me wanna cleanse my soul with genuine 80s teen movie night marathon.
BloodyMonday Rating:
Everybody's Fine (2009)
Meh. The movie serious lack of originality & characters development. Only Robert De Niro comes out fine in this schmaltzy, "Lifetime" movie-of-the-week plot.
BloodyMonday Rating:
Paper Heart (2009)
Twee delight... That's only two words I can think of right now.
BloodyMonday Rating:
Adam (2009)
A perfect companion to Mary & Max (one of the best animation of 2009), Adam is star-crossed love story (pun intended) between Adam, Asperger's Syndrome bearer, and Beth, free spirit woman. The picture wouldn’t be this intimate without stunning performance by Hugh Dancy. On the other hand, the lack of depth on why Beth would love someone like Adam, preventing me from wholeheartedly embraces her choice in the end (which is nice & perfect but requires a leap of faith). Otherwise, this is touching romantic film, which putting its feet firmly on the ground, making the world full of hope and seems nicer place to live.
BloodyMonday Rating:
The Invention of Lying (2009)
Expected to be like “Click” or “Yes Man”, where high-concept plot turned into endless gags, with moral lesson (forcefully) shoving down your throat. But "The Invention of Lying" is thinking man’s film. The whole concept is not seeing how first lying man exploits the ability. But it's about him finding the way not to lie, in order to find genuine happiness. Great stuff.
BloodyMonday Rating:
Give ‘Em Hell Malone (2009)
This is one damn frustrating experience. It’s like watching an infant trying to stand up and walk. They would take a few steps then fall their asses. In fact, kiddie film like “Bugsy Malone” has done better job paying a tribute to film noir than this borefest.
BloodyMonday Rating:
Zombieland (2009)
ถ้าอังกฤษมีหนังซอมบี้ฮาแตกอย่าง Shaun of the Dead แล้ว ทำไมอเมริกาจะมีบ้างไม่ได้... Zombieland คือการผสมผสานระหว่างบรรดาหนังซอมบี้เก่าๆ เข้ากับทัศนคติของคนสร้างที่อาจดูหนังแนวนี้มากเกินความจำเป็น จนสามารถสร้างหนังซอมบี้ที่เข้าใจสิ่งที่ตัวเองเป็น และเล่นสนุกไปกับกฏพื้นฐานของซอมบี้ได้อย่างเต็มที่ ทั้งนี้ทั้งนั้นต้องยกความดีให้สี่นักแสดงนำ โดยเฉพาะ วู้ดดี้ ฮาเรลสัน (เขาเกิดมาเพื่อบทนี้) ที่ช่วยกันสร้างมนต์เสน่ห์ ให้กับการเดินทางในโลกไร้มนุษย์ได้อย่างเต็มที่
หนังมีไอเดียกิ๊บเก๋ ทำออกมาได้สนุกสนานสไตล์ซิตคอมอังกฤษ โดยเฉพาะการนำกฏเหล็กต่างๆจากหนังที่เกี่ยวกับการท่องเวลา (ดูเหมือนว่า Back to the Future จะเป็นแรงบรรดาลใจหลัก) มาปู้ยี้ปู้ยำอย่างเมามัน ถึงแม้ว่าตลอดเวลาการรับชมจะให้ความรู้สึก เหมือนตัวเองกำลังดูซีรี่ย์ทางโทรทัศน์ แต่มันก็คือตอนที่ฮาที่สุดของซีซั่น แถมเอฟเฟ็คที่ใช้ก็มีคุณภาพจนคาดไม่ถึง
BloodyMonday Rating:
Looking for Eric (2009)
มีความรู้สึกว่าหนังเรื่องนี้มองโลกในแง่ดีเกินบรรยากาศโดยรวม จริงอยู่ว่าทุกสิ่งทุกอย่างที่ลงเอยด้วยดีในตอนสุดท้ายนั้น สามารถสร้างความสุขและรอยยิ้มให้กับคนดู แต่จากสถานการณ์ในเรื่องและบริบทที่เกิดขึ้นก่อนหน้านี้ มันยากที่จะทำใจเชื่อในสิ่งที่เห็น โดยเฉพาะพล็อตรองเกี่ยวกับปืน ซึ่งถ้าถูกตัดออกไปและหนังยังดำเนินเรื่องอย่างที่เป็นอยู่ Looking for Eric ก็น่าจะเป็นหนังฟีลกู้ดที่อบอุ่นที่สุดเรื่องหนึ่งของปีเลยทีเดียว
แวะมาส่งความสุขด้วยคน สุขสันต์วันเกิดมาก ๆๆๆ 
ฝากข้อความหลังไมค์
Rss Feed
ผู้ติดตามบล็อก : 1 คน [
หน้าสนจายยม๊ากกก สร้างจากเรื่องจริง
ในหุบเขา Elah